Court Overturns Negligence Dismissal for Mesothelioma Victim
News related to:DuBose Law Firm, PLLC · 2 min read
DALLAS, Nov. 18, 2026 /CourierPR/ -- In a significant legal decision, the Dallas Court of Appeals has overturned a previous dismissal of negligence claims brought by DuBose Law Firm on behalf of the family of Louie Scudder, a former refinery worker who died of mesothelioma in 2022. The Fifth District Court of Appeals in Dallas ruled that Scudder's asbestos exposure before 1971 does not bar his negligence claims against his employer, Tyler MD Holdings LLC.
The decision, issued on November 5, 2026, in the case of Scudder v. Tyler MD Holdings LLC, No. 05-23-01078-CV, held that Mr. Scudder's exposure to asbestos pipe insulation and insulating cement for years before 1971 does not preclude him from pursuing negligence claims against his employer. This ruling marks the first time a Texas court has considered whether pre-1971 asbestos exposure bars mesothelioma negligence claims against an employer.
Before August 30, 1971, the Texas workers' compensation law barred negligence lawsuits against employers only for certain listed injuries, and mesothelioma was never one of them. Mr. Scudder worked at the refinery from 1958 to 1964 and from 1966 until 1998, and was exposed to asbestos for years before 1971. Before trial, the court handling Texas asbestos cases dismissed every claim except gross negligence, ruling that the workers' compensation law barred the rest.
The Court of Appeals reversed this ruling and sent the case back to the trial court, allowing the Scudder family to pursue their negligence claims. The court found that Tyler MD Holdings LLC, the company responsible for the refinery's liabilities, was not a subscriber under Texas workers' compensation prior to 1971 as to mesothelioma because that disease was not recognized as a covered occupational disease under the act prior to 1971. The court also found that the insurance documents the employer offered for the years after 1971 did not prove coverage either.
The court upheld the jury's findings that asbestos at the refinery caused Mr. Scudder's death and that the company was grossly negligent. It rejected the company's argument that keeping exposure below Occupational Safety and Health Administration (OSHA) limits ruled out gross negligence, explaining that OSHA limits are a minimum standard and not a safe threshold for mesothelioma.
The Scudder family is represented by Ben K. DuBose and Greg W. Lisemby of DuBose Law Firm, Sean Cox of the Law Office of Sean Cox, and co-counsel Allen Hossley of Hossley Embry.
The case is Scudder v. Tyler MD Holdings LLC, No. 05-24-01078-CV, in the Court of Appeals for the Fifth District of Texas at Dallas, on appeal from the 192nd Judicial District Court of Dallas County. The parties may still seek review by the Supreme Court of Texas. If the decision stands, the case returns to the 192nd Judicial District Court of Dallas County for further proceedings on Mr. Scudder's common law negligence claims.